About
Website Transformation stage 3 looked at every form on the BHF site, and the donation form came first. It is where supporters give money for research, including people donating in memory of someone they have lost. The work was part of a wider Online Donations × CRO programme.
Scope
The one-off and monthly online donation journey, including the in-memory route and Gift Aid. The redesign also produced reusable form components (stepper, donation summary, Gift Aid, Keep in Touch, address finder), which were handed over to the UI team and the design system. Item collection and house clearance forms reused the Gift Aid work but were outside this journey.
The problem
People were dropping out
Only 38.2% of the people who entered the funnel finished. Analytics and Mouseflow showed where they left, field by field.
The page structure worked against them
The heuristic evaluation kept coming back to page structure: no sense of how long the form was, where you were in it, or what came next.
Gift Aid was hard to understand
The declaration was legal text that people skimmed or skipped, so donors missed a free 25% boost.
What we wanted to achieve
- Higher completion across the donation journey.
- Fewer validation errors.
- Shorter time to complete.
- New agreed baselines to measure against.
My role
- Research
- Analytics and Mouseflow review, heuristic evaluation, competitor review of donation summaries.
- Journey design
- The new four-step flow and the in-memory questions.
- Components
- I owned Gift Aid and the Donation summary, and worked on the stepper with Antonio Dell'Omo, who added it to the design library at handover.
- Testing
- The stepper sessions in Sept 2024, the Gift Aid design critique, and the final testing and affinity mapping of the redesigned form before handover.
The approach: four phases
- 01 · Discover
Find the drop-off
Analytics, Mouseflow, heuristic evaluation, CRO insights.
- 02 · Define
Agree the target
Focus areas, KPIs, a traffic-light status for each form element.
- 03 · Design & test
Build and compare
Components, journeys, stepper prototypes, design critique.
- 04 · Validate
Test the whole form
Moderated testing of the full redesigned form, then affinity mapping.
DiscoverFinding the drop-off
We started with the numbers. Google Analytics showed where people entered and left each journey. Mouseflow showed what they did in each field. Then the UX team ran a heuristic evaluation, rating every issue by severity. The most severe issues clustered around page structure. A CRO insights board added motivations, impacts and recommendations.

Design & testThe new journey: four steps
Your donation → Your details → Payment → Thank you. Best practice says 3–5 steps. Each step says how far along you are and what comes next ("2 of 4 · Next: Payment"), and Back appears from step two onwards.
Design & testThe stepper, tested
Two navigation designs went into testing: a horizontal stepper and a radial "wheel". We ran four moderated sessions on 12–13 Sept 2024, at the BHF Camden shop, at head office and remotely. Participants made a £20 in-memory donation, added Gift Aid, then went back to change their details. The radial design shows one step at a time with the next step named beside it, and that was the version we took forward.

Design & testGift Aid, in practice
Gift Aid adds 25% to a donation at no cost to the donor, but only if they understand it and tick the box. The copy had to come from Fundraising Compliance and be signed off by Legal, so the design had to do the explaining:
- A plain headline, "Boost your donation by 25%", with the declaration hidden until the box is ticked.
- The Gift Aid logo kept, because people recognise it and it draws the eye.
- A worked example: your £20 is worth £25.
We tested placement, background, logo and helper link in an internal design critique, and made separate versions for money and for donated goods.

Design & testDonation summary, in practice
Three of the four charities we reviewed had no donation summary. The new form shows the amount as a banner under the stepper and again before payment, with Edit links back to each step, so donors always know what they're giving.
ValidateWhat testing told us
Before handover to development, we tested the full redesigned form with five participants and grouped their feedback into six themes: Usability & flow, Tone & sensitivity, Gift Aid, Transparency & trust, Preferences & flexibility, and Clarity of copy.

Four key trends
Warmth works, if it's optional. People liked the compassionate tone, but some hesitated when asked to share a personal story.
→ explain why we ask, and let people skip
Motivation questions need framing. The "how long ago" question felt intrusive this early in the journey.
→ mark optional, or move later
Gift Aid still needed simpler words. One participant skipped it every time because she didn't understand it.
→ bite-size copy and a tooltip
Labels need to say what they do. Some participants missed "Edit", and "details" and "donate" were overused.
→ clearer labels, less repetition
What testing decided
Soften the story request
Make it clearly optional and explain what Heart Stories are.
Simplify Gift Aid
Bite-size copy, a "How it works" tooltip and a visible £20 → £25.
Clearer labels
"Change amount" and "Review details" instead of "Edit"; motivation questions marked optional.
Key numbers
Outcomes & reflection
The redesigned form went live in 2025. Comparing Nov 2024 – Mar 2025 with Dec 2025 – May 2026, the share of people who completed a donation rose from 38.2% to 45.6%, and abandonment fell from 61.7% to 54.4%. With 71,746 people entering the funnel in the second period, that's roughly 5,300 more completed donations than the old rate would have produced.
These are before-and-after figures, not an A/B test. The two periods cover different months, and other CRO work ran alongside, so I treat the rise as the redesign's direction of travel rather than its exact effect.
If I did it again, I'd test the in-memory questions with bereaved supporters earlier. They turned out to be the most sensitive part of the form, and the hardest to get right from inside the team.
“It feels human, like you are talking to me.”

